"Blu-ray Disc" with SD encoding?
On eBay, I got an alleged Blu-ray Disc of the recent Japanese movie Sukiyaki Western Django. It appears to be NOT a Blu-ray Disc, but in trying to determine this, I've grown confused about the definitions.
The official Japanese Blu-ray release is, according to the only source I could find, an "AVC/MPEG-4" encode. This disc is MPEG-2.
If I turn off the upscaling on my PS3, the TV says the input is 720x480.
The disc plays in my Oppo DVD player.
The box -- a standard DVD case -- says "Blu-ray Disc" and has the blue swoosh logo...but it also says "DVD video", "DVD-9," and "Hi-Bit Edition." The DVD case comes within a slipcase, which includes an explanation of "Hi-Bit DVD" as what sounds like "SuperBit."
I'm now assuming that this is a bootleg, and that it's not, in any meaningful way, a "Blu-ray Disc." But, as I was looking through the big Blu-ray FAQ, it seemed as though there are things defined as, in the broad sense Blu-ray, with this SD output. And that there are DVD-9s that are in some way "Blu-ray."
In any case, this sure as hell isn't a "high definition transfer." And I'm ticked. But, before I raise hell with the vendor, I'm wondering whether it's somehow legal for this sort of release to be called a "Blu-ray disc."
