U wont have LUCk Suri Bhen ji on that one!!Rani didnt show much Better luck next time!! may be GIRL FRIEND?

Without doubt HUM TUM is not original, but then which story is these days. But Kohli proves he can write smartly and urbanely (not yet where Farhan Akhtar is perhaps). Obviously Aditya Chopra had a lot to do with the creative inputs....there's an inherent hangover of WHEN HARRY MET SALLY in all of Chopra's films, from the days of DIL TOH PAGAL HAI...(what with couples from various strata of life telling you how they got together - straight lift from WHMS), but that is a different grouse. HUM-TUM copies WHMS to a greater extent, Indianising dialogues like 'A man and woman can never be friends, because.....' - I leave it incomplete for all those who have not seen either to maybe enjoy, yet it is recommended watching.

HUM TUM stands out for a rock-solid performance by Saif Ali Khan. Whether he is chasing skirts or whether he is frustrated or whether he is angry, or simply flirtatious, he does it rather well. I think he has finally graduated out of the supporting hero role mould. He really needs to choose films wisely now. He has it in him to give Aamir Khan a run for his money, if he sticks to his guns as far as roles are concerned(but I do not think he is as thinking of an actor as AK is)....He does possess more talent than SRK does, so he better cash in on it.

Go watch it for some snazzy dialogues, SAK's great performance and hindi cinema finally showing a lead couple in bed alluding to pre-marital conjugation AND the heroine NOT FEELING too terrible about it. Baby steps now, we might finally be growing up !!!

HUM TUM is very urban film, low buget will favour imho, but does not have UNIVERSAL MASS APPEAL..

It is more PALTABLE than MDK(simply disgusting), But I prefer MYKSH on this one any days, despite Saif etc!

I was dragged into seeing this film, I honestly wasn't looking forward to watching it to any extent. However, at it's end, and to my surprise, Hum Tum is an enjoyably cute film. It's a commendable improvement on Kunal Kohli's end as both a writer and a director. Unlike his debut, his contempo is a tad more fearless and humanly distinguished. It's also an improvement version of "When Harry Met Sally"(which Hum Tum is inspired from). The latter film is far more lovable from it's irritating predecessor. Don't overlook this one as "another Yashraj films banner cheese feast"(no offense intended Mr_Khiladi )

WOW Dvd Collector, I didn't expect you to like this type of film. I have to definitely check out "Hum Tum" now. What did you think of Saif and Rani in the film?

Go watch it for some snazzy dialogues, SAK's great performance and hindi cinema finally showing a lead couple in bed alluding to pre-marital conjugation AND the heroine NOT FEELING too terrible about it. Baby steps now, we might finally be growing up !!!

WOW Dvd Collector, I didn't expect you to like this type of film. I have to definitely check out "Hum Tum" now. What did you think of Saif and Rani in the film?

Gonna see this on Fri (weather permittin!)

My question tho is... since it's based on When Harry Met Sally, do they, um... have Rani doin an orgasm scene while they're sitting at a daba or somethin?

Watching it once!! and make your own opinion!! will be the way to go imho,if u dont have to watch any thing better!! wont harm at all!! or better wait Collector's reply/recomendation!!

i did watch!! and I am not REPENTING at least!

Arsh, I didn't mean to offend you or anything. I value your opinion as well but DVD Collector practically hated every film this year barring his remarks on "Khakee" and "Ek Hasina Thi" - which he thought was average so that's why I was surprised he would like a film like "Hum Tum". I loved "Ek Hasina Thi" - it's my favorite film of the year. But, I also thought "Khakee" was average. Anyway, I have a question for both of you - arsh and DVD Collector. Since you guys have seen "Hum Tum", did Saif do better in EHT of "Hum Tum"? I like to know.

a la SRK style, as long he SRK is playing SRK he is fine!! as soon as he try to sneak out of SRK shell, he fails miserably imho).