abushamat wrote:
arsh wrote:
Lata Mangeshkar releases music of Umrao Jaan
By MIO Team
Oct 03, 2006, 17:50
Printer friendly page
Was J P Dutta’s inviting Lata Mangeshkar to release the music of his Umrao Jaan a stint to get over the Asha Bhosle effect from his film? Lyricist Javed Akhtar was given the task of inviting her to the function as it is said that she never refuses him. Both of them share a warm camaraderie with each other. Eventually she turned up for the function.
Inside source informs, "Asking Lata Mangeshkar to release the music of the film was an ingenuous way to break the aura of Asha Bhonsle that surrounds the earlier Umrao Jaan. J P Dutta is absolutely fed up of the comparisons with the Muzzafar Ali’s film. People are constantly comparing the two. He wanted the comparisons to stop. And what better place to begin with, than the music? J P saw Lata as their saving grace, whose presence at the music function could deflect attention from the National award-winning mujras that Ashaji sang for Rekha in the earlier film. J P hopes the desired effect has been achieved, and music lovers will now look at this Umrao Jaan in a different light.He hopes that now Anu Malik-Alka Yagnik's combined efforts in J P's Umrao Jaan acquired a profile very different from the Khayyam-Asha Bhosle combination in Muzzafar Ali's Umrao Jaan.â€
© Copyright 2006 by MusicIndiaOnLine.com
Top of Page
I think that Alka Yagnik will not be able to do justice to the songs-Even at her age Asha Bhosle would do a splendid rendition of Umrao--
alka has been lying low lately, and bit out of form, but she is capable though, if not better than asha!
but to surpass khyam, asha, rekha, muzzafar ali, shahryaar, is not only monumental but impossible!!imho
Aish vaish do not stand a chance, here and there!
but I am glad, dutta once forever used his right common sense to create fresh compositions, not to recycle and butcher classic compositions, score!
Dutta has best track record of working successfuly with annu malik and Javed akhtar, and they will be possibly able to pull a good one again..I hope
As long as it is not a rehashed and butchered Don, kinda soundtrack, with its individual identity, I am happy!
It is ironical that Don will go in the annals

as the one of most successful soundtrack by SEL, and RDB as best work by rehman!
