It is currently Mon Nov 17, 2025 7:17 pm

All times are UTC




Post new topic Reply to topic  [ 73 posts ]  Go to page Previous  1, 2, 3, 4, 5  Next
Author Message
 Post subject:
PostPosted: Tue Feb 03, 2004 12:05 am 
Offline

Joined: Mon Dec 03, 2001 8:48 pm
Posts: 335
"Yeh Rishta" is without a doubt one of the most intoxicating songs I've heard in recent memory. I've already listened to it six times in a row since coming home, and I still find it invigorating. As for the rest of the album, I can't say I was blown away. Without a doubt, it's a must-buy, but it seems that nothing quite compares to that first track.


Top
 Profile  
 
 Post subject:
PostPosted: Tue Feb 03, 2004 1:16 am 
Offline

Joined: Mon Dec 03, 2001 5:53 pm
Posts: 14989
[that it is ARRs best since DIL SE.]

I'll respectfuly differ with u shiv on this one!!

I think, Rehman had a number of very good albums since DIL SE!

I dont think, imho, MEENAXI is on par with ZUBAIDA or LAGAAN or TAAL..I even think, Saathiya was a bit superior!

But on other note..Meenaxi is one of ARR 's VERY GOOD ONES!

WHILE, LAKEER was one of his WORST!

TEHZEEB was kinda average to good affair!

then u have 1947 earth, dil se, Takshak, Pukar there in GOOD to VERY GOOD category!


Top
 Profile  
 
 Post subject:
PostPosted: Tue Feb 03, 2004 3:03 am 
Offline

Joined: Mon Aug 05, 2002 6:12 am
Posts: 91
i would put tehzeeb in the same category with 1947 and thakshak...and lakeer on a rank way below that (although rhythm would be much higher)....but just my own opinion and taste of music makes meenaxi better than the rest for me, personally. I don't know whether its the initial intoxication im getting from it because of its recent release, but imo, if i were stuck on a stranded island and could only take 3 albums with me, they would be, in this order:

dil se
meenaxi
taal

lagaan and saathiya/alaipayuthey go on the same level for me as bombay and zubeidaa...

but its just everyones own call on this one!

we differ in that respect, but you gotta say, meenaxi is one damn good album!!!


Top
 Profile  
 
 Post subject:
PostPosted: Wed Feb 04, 2004 5:07 pm 
Offline

Joined: Mon Dec 03, 2001 5:53 pm
Posts: 14989
I did agree that MEENAXI is ONE OF REHMAN's GOOD-VERY GOOD ones!!

RE ZUBAID!! if u ask me, EVEN AR himself even after being HAJI cant do another ZUBAIDA!! I bet!!

He can do..Many Meenaxi's possible LAGAAN, TAAL and DIL SE!

GHAII, will GET, BEST out of him, because of his own SPECTACULAR taste for music!!

LAGAAN/TAAL/ZUBAIDA/DIL SE were unique in sense, u did not feel, that HAS BEEN HEARD BEFORE!!

MEENAXI..Instrumental...kinda sound like TAAL..

Rang hai..Sounds like maen hun albeli, rang de..combination..same musical raaga, wuth different beats!!

ZUBAIDA!! is REAL CLASS!!whether some one likes that kinda music or not..

u can bring 1000 anus, N-S, darbars and Rehmans all together..u wont get ZUBAIDA again..PERIOD!


Top
 Profile  
 
 Post subject:
PostPosted: Wed Feb 04, 2004 7:34 pm 
Offline

Joined: Wed Dec 05, 2001 3:16 am
Posts: 4259
Meenaxi isn't quite up to Rahman's very best works but it is excellent.

BTW, is Mithun in this film? It looks like him in one of the inlay photos, next to Tabu in red.


Top
 Profile  
 
 Post subject:
PostPosted: Wed Feb 04, 2004 11:18 pm 
Offline

Joined: Mon Aug 05, 2002 6:12 am
Posts: 91
ew no, thats not mithun...thats the guy that was in dil se and lagaan...cant recall his name =/ but he was the chicken guy in lagaan! hehe


Top
 Profile  
 
 Post subject:
PostPosted: Thu Feb 05, 2004 3:26 am 
Offline

Joined: Wed Dec 05, 2001 3:16 am
Posts: 4259
shivrk wrote:
ew no, thats not mithun...thats the guy that was in dil se and lagaan...cant recall his name =/ but he was the chicken guy in lagaan! hehe

Raguvir Yadav.


Top
 Profile  
 
 Post subject:
PostPosted: Fri Feb 06, 2004 1:35 am 
Offline

Joined: Mon Dec 03, 2001 8:48 pm
Posts: 335
Okay shivrk, I now totally agree. Can I retract my earlier statements? This is a brilliant masterwork of a soundtrack! I've been listening to the songs over and over again (what you must do to truly appreciate any Rahman music) and each and every song is perfection. From the full length songs to the instrumental pieces, I am in love.

My anticipation for this movie cannot be fully articulated in words.

My preference:

THE MASTERPIECES (Per. Fec. Tion.)
1. Dil Se.. (Classic for the ages)
2. Meenaxi: A Tale of Three Cities
3. Kandukonden Kandukonden
4. Zubeidaa (this doesn't get enough love)
5. Taal
6. Lagaan

EXCELLENT
7. Bombay
8. Rangeela
9. Tehzeeb (this as well. Love every song except the inexplicable "Diya Mirza goes f**king nuts" song)
10. Alai Payuthey
11. Thakshak
12. One Two Ka Four (this too)
13. Legend of Baghat Singh
14. Doli Saja Ke Rakhna

REALLY F**KING GOOD
15. Pukar
16. Kannathil Muthamittal
17. Daud
18. 1947
19. Nayak
20. Hindustani

THE GOOD
21. Kabhi Na Kabhi
22. The Gentleman

THE AVERAGE
23. Lakeer
24. Saathiya (why don't I just get out my copy of ALAI PAYUTHEY instead? So much better...)
25. Dil Hi Dil Mein

THE BAD
26. Love You Hameshaa (the only truly "bad" soundtrack by Rahman)

THE TERRIBLE
None

Obviously a big Rahman fan over here!




Edited By kamran on 1076032554


Top
 Profile  
 
 Post subject:
PostPosted: Fri Feb 06, 2004 2:29 am 
Offline

Joined: Mon Dec 03, 2001 5:53 pm
Posts: 14989
I'll Take MEENAXi, demote to Excellent, Take Tehzeeb, move to GOOD, Take Saathiya, move to very good, i am not including tamil versions here!

Love u hamesha!! I think, was still better than L:AKEER :baaa: :bangbang: :keh:




Edited By arsh on 1076086652


Top
 Profile  
 
 Post subject:
PostPosted: Fri Feb 06, 2004 5:28 am 
Offline

Joined: Mon Aug 05, 2002 6:12 am
Posts: 91
kamran wrote:
Okay shivrk, I now totally agree. Can I retract my earlier statements? This is a brilliant masterwork of a soundtrack! I've been listening to the songs over and over again (what you must do to truly appreciate any Rahman music) and each and every song is perfection. From the full length songs to the instrumental pieces, I am in love.

My anticipation for this movie cannot be fully articulated in words.

My preference:

THE MASTERPIECES (Per. Fec. Tion.)
1. Dil Se.. (Classic for the ages)
2. Meenaxi: A Tale of Three Cities
3. Kandukonden Kandukonden
4. Zubeidaa (this doesn't get enough love)
5. Taal
6. Lagaan

EXCELLENT
7. Bombay
8. Rangeela
9. Tehzeeb (this as well. Love every song except the inexplicable "Diya Mirza goes f**king nuts" song)
10. Alai Payuthey
11. Thakshak
12. One Two Ka Four (this too)
13. Legend of Baghat Singh
14. Doli Saja Ke Rakhna

REALLY F**KING GOOD
15. Pukar
16. Kannathil Muthamittal
17. Daud
18. 1947
19. Nayak
20. Hindustani

THE GOOD
21. Kabhi Na Kabhi
22. The Gentleman

THE AVERAGE
23. Lakeer
24. Saathiya (why don't I just get out my copy of ALAI PAYUTHEY instead? So much better...)
25. Dil Hi Dil Mein

THE BAD
26. Love You Hameshaa (the only truly "bad" soundtrack by Rahman)

THE TERRIBLE
None

Obviously a big Rahman fan over here!

that is like my list VERBATEM!

but, i would move khabhi na khabi up one level...ahhh, i love meenaxi. rang hai and dhuan are definetly my faves as of now...


Top
 Profile  
 
 Post subject:
PostPosted: Sat Feb 07, 2004 4:56 pm 
Offline

Joined: Mon Dec 03, 2001 5:53 pm
Posts: 14989
WShiv ji, badhai ho..meenaxi gets a perfect sixer from gandhi ji:

Meenaxi

Producer: Culture of The Street Films
Director: M.F. Hussain
Starring: Tabu,Raghuvir Yadav, Kunal Kapoor, Nadira Babbar, and Sandhya Shetty
Music: A.R. Rahman
Lyrics: Rahat Indori, M.F. Hussain, and Sukhwinder Singh
Singers: Reena Bharadwaj, Sukhwinder Singh, Sonu Nigam, Asha Bhonsle, Kunal Ganjawalla, Alka Yagnik, Dallinda, Murtaza Khan, and Quadir Khan
Audio On: Sony Music
Number of Songs: 8
Released on: January 24, 2004
Reviewed by: Aakash Gandhi
Reviewer's Rating: 10 out of 10
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Cumulative Rating: 7.25 out of 10
Rated by: 20 unique users

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Enter your Rating: 1 out of 10 2 out of 10 3 out of 10 4 out of 10 5 out of 10 6 out of 10 7 out of 10 8 out of 10 9 out of 10 10 out of 10



A.R. Rahman…a man who breathes music…speaks music…lives music… “If you have Santosh and Rahman, anybody can make a good film” M.F. Hussain

How sweet it is! Just when you think he is starting to slack off, he creates magic. Just when you think he is losing his creative touch, he re-innovates the beauty of music. Just when you think he’s out of it, he composes a soulful masterpiece. Meenaxi is nothing short of a magnum opus, in terms of its music or as a film. This is M.F. Hussain’s second directorial venture after his first film, Gaja Gamini, failed to pull in the cine-goers. This time, the renowned artist-painter has roped in the best in the business including Tabu to play the title role, Santosh Siven to direct the cameras, and music legend, A.R. Rahman, to bring a simple touch of music to Meenaxi…and what a touch it is.

Going through a dry-spell, if one may call it so, A.R. Rahman had only one hindi release in 2003, in the form of Tehzeeb. Unfortunately this one only caught the attention of the critics, calling it an above-average album. Above average and A.R. Rahman, does that really match? But you can’t blame Haji Rahman for this as in the year 2003, our beloved composer went abroad; composing for the stage acts of Lord of the Rings and China’s official Oscar entry, Warriors of Heaven and Earth. His first release in 2004, Lakeer, didn’t really find any place for success, as only about half the songs got recognized. Then came the end of January…and so the deliverance of Meenaxi.

With a tagline as “Tale of 3 Cities,” Meenaxi is shot in 3 exotic locales: Hyderabad, Prague, and Jaisalmer. The film has Tabu in the lead role. It’s almost given that with her in the lead, this film has the full potential of being a super-hit. With Tabu all set to take on the stunning locations of Hyderabad, Prague, and Jaisalmer, let’s just see how good the music is…

1) Yeh Rishta

Yeh Rishta is the first shot of Meenaxi and is Tabu’s solo entrance piece. The song starts off on a beautiful note and never lets down. The beautiful note is the voice of debutant Reena Bharadwaj. Her opening line, and the opening of her career, is as soothing as running water and just bewilders you. Her rendition of the entire track is superb, but in particular the feeling with which she sings the title line “Yeh Rishta Kya kehe laata hai” is perfect. Speaking of perfect, A.R. Rahman simply amazes! The way he builds the beat of a tabla-like drum throughout the entire song is uncanny and sets a pace at which Reena sings with ease. Reaching a midpoint in the song, begins the unique integration of strings, supplied nicely by John Themis. To top it all off, Rahman superimposes a synthesized beat into the background that only adds to the flavor of this colorful track. Just when you think that it can’t get any better, the Genius adds the sound of flowing water to accompany Reena Bharadwaj, creating the most peaceful effect. Lyrically, Rahat Indori pens some very meaningful lines. Throughout the album, he proves to be a top-notch lyricist by bringing words and emotions to life. An interesting tid-bit to add to this number is that Rahman requested Reena to give an audition in his studio apartment in London and ended up recording the scratch version in his kitchen! That’s Mr. Rahman for you…doesn’t get his nutrition from food, but from his music!

2) Chinnamma Chilakkamma

No, don’t worry this isn’t one of Rahman’s Tamil hits or remakes. Rather, it’s an excellent mixture of western beats fused together with Telagu folk. As odd as it may sound, Rahman once again weaves his magical touch all over this one to create another chart-busting hit. This piece is initiated by one of Rahman’s favorite instruments, the flute. He then leads the pan flute to blend into the opening line “Chinnamma Chilakkamma” and here on out begins a simply awesome number. The line Chinnamma Chilakkamma is so catchy that you’ll be tapping your feet before you even know it! The lucky voice that will be featured on this Rahman rhythm is Mr. Sukhwinder Singh. The heavy drumming coped together with some of Rahman’s signature electrical beats back up the western aspect of the song, while the traditional flute and percussions, along with the lyrics of Chinnamma Chilakkamma, round up the Telagu Folk aspect of the song. Being set in the beautiful regions of Hyderabad, this song may even challenge the amazing setting of Rahman’s great “Chaiyya Chaiyya,” which was stunningly choreographed on top of a train by Farah Khan, we’ll just have to see for ourselves. Speaking of Chaiyya Chaiyya, there was a lot of buzz going around the industry saying that this may be the next Chaiyya Chaiyya as Sukhi and Rahman team up to create an extremely catchy piece. It was said that Singh had requested Rahman if he could change before the recording of the song. Surprised yet? Maybe now…he came out wearing a sexy netted black vest so he could “get into the mood.” I guess that explains the authentic feel to Sukhwinder’s silky smooth vocals. Oh yeah, Sukhi penned this one himself…you’ve got to be surprised now!



3) Do Kadam Aur Sahi

M.F. Hussain originally titled this film Do Kadam Aur Sahi, but as time progressed he believed that Meenaxi suited the film better. Before the switch, Rahman had already composed the what-would-have-been title track. Undoubtedly this is the best track of the album. If you thought that Sonu Nigam sounded nice in the title track of Kal Ho Naa Ho then be prepared to be surprised because Sonu Nigam has really out done himself this time. A.R. Rahman always has a way of bringing out the best of people as he did with Sonu in their previous hit together, Saathiya. This song will definitely appeal to the masses as well as the classes. Set to the lush scenery of Jaisalmer and Prague, this piece should create an even more peaceful and resounding effect, if that’s even conceivable. The beauty in this piece lies in it’s vocal-musical melding. Rahman doesn’t add a single “hard” beat, yet he creates an evenly symmetrical rhythm that flows nicely. Overlapping, is Sonu Nigam’s rendition, as pure as can be, and really does raise the feeling and emotion of the song greatly. The line Do Kadam Aur Sahi has such a simple yet catchy melody that Sonu’s voice will literally be stuck in your ears and hearts for days on end. Rahat Indori’s words are extremely touching. He writes on a place not too far away, a place where everything is shining bright with light, a place where hearts are filled with freely glowing flames and where love is all-pervasive. A land just a few more steps away…I promise you, your heart will skip a beat while listening to this spectacle of sound.

4) Dhuan Dhuan

"For one song, we started with no tune and no lyrics either. One afternoon I bumped into Lataji and Ashaji in London. I asked Ashaji if she’d do a song with me the next day. She had to go to Scotland the next day. But she returned in a few days and we finished the track Dua dua in four hours in London.” – A.R. Rahman [Filmfare]

It was heard that Ashaji had cut her vacation plans short to record this song for A.R. Rahman out of utter respect for Mr. Hussain. That’s not all; she reportedly did the song for free! All that is well and good but with what quality did she render the song? Remember how I said it seems as if Rahman saab always brings out the best of every singer he’s ever worked with, Asha Bhonsle is no exception. After teaming up in the chartbusting Meherbaan of Tehzeeb, the pair comes together once again to construct a hard-core piece to say the least. Ashaji’s rendition of the line Na na na naa will get you every time. This ever-youthful vocalist proves to the nation why she is still in the business even after many decades. Kunal Ganjawalla, the current favorite of all music directors it seems, is featured with Rahman after their chartbuster Oh Hum Dum from Saathiya. Although he appears for a very short time, he does a nice job in opening the track. A.R. Rahman’s choice of music is great. His choice of heavy percussions, provided by the much talked about Shivamani, and synthesized rhythms provide great support to Asha Bhonsle’s vocal strength. Once again, Rahman provides us with an extremely fresh and feel good number. This song will be shot in the midst of the city of Prague. It should be noted that M.F. Hussain chose this song as one of his all-time favorites, stated in the Marathi Daily Loksatta.

5) Rang Hai

“It is the music of the film. It just did something to me. It´s almost divine.” – Tabu

Now that we have been through Hyderabad and in Prague, Rang Hai takes us into the land of Rajashtan…Jaiselmar. A.R. Rahman does a superb job in incorporating some Rajasthani folk while adding a little western twist to it all, and still making the end result as sweet as sugar or as smooth as silk, whichever you prefer! The most unusual part of the track is the very beginning, opening with a mysterious voice of the Lebanese singer Dallinda. Rahman’s use of percussions, provided by ace percussionist Hossam Ramzy, is ingenious. Alka Yagnik is the one in charge vocally and does complete justice to the song. In her rendition, which is first class, she sounds a bit like Reena Bharadwaj, or maybe that’s just her voice still lingering in the back of my mind from the first track! This is a real colorful track; (no pun intended) with Ramzy supplying some heavy drumming and clever purcussioning, Dalinda’s shaky vocals conveying an eery yet fresh feeling, Alka breathing a lot of enthusiasm into the piece, and Rahman mixing and matching western with Rajasthani folk at ease, this track is definitely a winner all the way. On a side note; An interesting feature to look for while watching the film is Tabu’s performance to this piece. At the time of shooting, she had four stitches in her leg, yet she still danced relentlessly, later saying, “It is the music of the film. It just did something to me. It’s almost divine.” Now Mr. Rahman is literally healing people with his music…

6) Noor-Un-Ala

“There is a qawwali written by me and sung by classical musicians Ustad Ghulam Mustafa and his son for which Rahman has tuned unusual music. The film opens with this qawwali, the picturisation of which is a major highlight…The qawwali is exultant about the presence of the light and what a light it is! It is a Sufi thought, a thought that keep us going even when there is pitch darkness.” – M.F. Hussain [The Hindu]

Who said that A.R. Rahman doesn’t have an ear for classical music? You can throw all that out the window after you give this quawwali a listen. Rahman gives the honor to the sensational duo of Murtaza Khan and Quadir Khan. They fill the song with alaps and swaras of the like and really show that they have the talent and skill required to be worth the opportunity of singing for the virtuosic Rahman. Like every other song in this soundtrack, this song will have you on a beat right away. Never letting down, Rahman continuously provides us with the quick-paced beat of the tabla and the flowing melody of the harmonium, characteristic of most modern quawwalis. The title line Noor-Un-Ala is extremely catchy and will have you singing it in no time. Mr. Hussain does it all! Either it be his unique painting skill, his aptness of directing huge films, and here, his ability to pen some nice lyrics, which is quite difficult to do when writing for a qawwali I might add! There’s an interesting story that goes along with this. M.F. Hussain had originally hired a lyricist to write this qawwali. Unfortunately the poor lyricist decided to center the song on one of the most commonly used lyrical words, Ishq. Mr. Hussain took one look at the words and decided to write the song for himself! I wouldn’t be surprised if that original lyricist was Sameer, but it’s just a hunch. Also, watch out for this one on big screen as it is picturized in pouring rain, and choreographed by Italian National Award Winning choreographer Illiana Czhtaristi.

7) Cyclist’s Rhythm

"Yesterday there was a ballet of bicycles at night. We filmed the scene where Tabu is caught in the street amidst the bicycles and Rahman´s score is innovative in this." – M.F. Hussain [The Hindu]

How creative can someone get? This instrumental proves that A.R. Rahman, without a doubt is the most innovative composer of all time, crossing so many boundaries! To us lay people, the bell of a cycle would sound rather annoying and irritating, but to Musical Mastermind A.R. Rahman, even the sounds of bells ring the sweet sound of music. Special mention must be given to Shivamani who does wonders with the percussions. The beginning of this instrumental piece starts off with Rahman’s bicycle bells chiming away nicely to the background drum beats. The bells then lead into a masterly composed flute performance by Shivamani in the foreground of some subtle yet very innovative Rahman beats. In the middle of the piece, Rahman brings the harmonic background to a halt and just has the sound of the bicycle bells in a short interim. From here on begins the fun. Soon after the bells fade away, the percussion starts to pick up. The drumbeats get louder, up to the point where they are thundering loud, accompanied by some powerful percussion instruments. A.R. Rahman and Shivamani create a great atmosphere towards the end with the whistling and the fast beats. No doubt you’ll be up dancing with the drums in no time.

8) Potter’s Village

This is the second instrumental by A.R. Rahman and it picks up right where the last one left off. This one carries an Arabic feel to it, most probably because of the extensive use of the guitar throughout the piece. This time Hossam Ramzy takes over the reigns for the percussion composition. Rahman, with his mastery over innovation, is able to add a new spin on this one with the variety at which he utilizes his instruments. The tune that is played by the guitar is very catchy, especially when coupled together with the new percussion instruments introduced by Rahman. Similar to the previous instrumental this one really picks up speed in the second half and is a joy to listen to.

Without a doubt, this is A.R. Rahman’s best musical score since Taal, if not the best of his career. For A.R. Rahman has proved, ad nozium, that he is the most innovative music director ever and the most brilliant. This Musical Genius is now an international force to reckon with. With beautiful locations such as Hyderabad, Prague, and Jaisalmer, set to the delicate melodies of A.R. Rahman, Meenaxi is truly a sight for the eyes to feast on and an intonation for the ears to savor.


Top
 Profile  
 
 Post subject:
PostPosted: Sat Feb 07, 2004 8:27 pm 
Offline

Joined: Mon Aug 05, 2002 6:12 am
Posts: 91
that review makes me so happy. :D :thumbs: :laugh:


Top
 Profile  
 
 Post subject:
PostPosted: Sat Feb 07, 2004 10:13 pm 
Offline

Joined: Mon Dec 03, 2001 5:53 pm
Posts: 14989
I knew that, t5hats why, i posted it..cheers..my rating 9/10


Top
 Profile  
 
 Post subject:
PostPosted: Tue Feb 10, 2004 7:58 am 
Offline

Joined: Tue Jan 29, 2002 10:52 pm
Posts: 29
Location: Chi-town
I absolutely love this soundtrack. I've been listening to "Yeh Rishta", "Chinnamma Chilakkamma", "Noor-un-ala", and "Rang Hai" over and over again after getting them from CoolGoose. I'm not really a big expert on Rahman's music, just a big fan. And I still love "Lagaan" and "Dil Se.." as his best works. But this is far up there.

On a side note...does anyone know where I can get good copies of "Dhuan Dhuan" and "Do Kadam Aur Sahi"? Those didn't really come out well in mp3, and I know it's not doing those songs justice.


Top
 Profile  
 
 Post subject:
PostPosted: Tue Feb 10, 2004 4:34 pm 
Offline

Joined: Mon Dec 03, 2001 5:53 pm
Posts: 14989
Holden, yaar!! come on!! GO GRAB THE ORIGINAL MAN!! I bet u will enjoy more!! :baaa:


Top
 Profile  
 
Display posts from previous:  Sort by  
Post new topic Reply to topic  [ 73 posts ]  Go to page Previous  1, 2, 3, 4, 5  Next

All times are UTC


Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 3 guests


You cannot post new topics in this forum
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
You cannot edit your posts in this forum
You cannot delete your posts in this forum

Search for:
Jump to:  
Powered by phpBB® Forum Software © phpBB Group