It is currently Mon Nov 17, 2025 4:05 pm

All times are UTC




Post new topic Reply to topic  [ 10 posts ] 
Author Message
PostPosted: Wed Jan 14, 2004 5:00 pm 
Offline

Joined: Mon Dec 03, 2001 5:53 pm
Posts: 14989
'Paap' exciting!

By Taran Adarsh, January 14th, 2004 - 0930 hrs IST


Many a times, producers bow down to market diktats and end up making films that are ancient history soon after they've hit the marquee. Their 'life' at the box-office is short-lived primarily because the passion to create something exciting is missing.

But you do come across that rare film which lingers in your memory and remains etched even after months have elapsed. Pooja Bhatt's PAAP [produced by Shreya Creations P. Ltd. and Fisheye Network P. Ltd.] is one such film that stays with you!

In an era where most writers/directors focus on gimmicks while the story takes a complete backseat, PAAP stands out as an exception. Here's a story that's refreshingly different from what you've viewed so far. The focus is clearly on content, not gimmicks.

PAAP marks Pooja's directorial debut and although on new turf, she has created an engrossing fare that is visually stunning and thematically moving. The film is extremely successful in drawing the viewer into its world and, accordingly, is worth every minute that you spent viewing it.

Brilliantly shot by cinematographer Anshuman Mahaley [the locales of Spiti cannot be described in mere words!] and efficiently edited by Akiv Ali, PAAP heralds the arrival of yet another gifted director – Pooja Bhatt.

Tackling a serious theme in her very first film must've been nothing short of a challenge. And Pooja emerges trumps. The deft handling of the story manages to keep the viewer enticed for the next two hours [12 reels].

Besides Pooja's proficient storytelling, PAAP boasts of brilliantly-penned dialogues that are soaked in emotions [Niranjan Iyengar], a tight and almost flawless screenplay [Mahesh Bhatt] and scintillating performances by the entire cast.

John Abraham takes giant strides as an actor. The kind of maturity he reflects in his third film is rare. Dr. Mohan Agashe is superb [the confrontation scene between John and Agashe is outstanding]. Denzil Smith is first-rate, while Sandeep Mehta is an actor to watch. Child artiste Madan Bhiku is next to perfect.

However, it is new-find Udita Goswami who surprises you with a performance that is sure to find a place in all award nominations next year. You can't help but put your two hands together for this bravura performance!

The music gels well with the narrative. 'Intezaar' [music: Anu Malik; singer: Anuradha Paudwal] and 'Lagan' [music: Shahi; singer: Rahat Fateh Ali Khan] are the pick of the lot.

All in all, PAAP is one film that is sure to be noticed. Noticed for its performances. Noticed for the story, screenplay and dialogues. Noticed for the strong visual appeal… But more than anything else, it'll be noticed for the transition of a talented actress to a good producer to a sensitive storyteller [director].

When Pooja looks back at her career, may be 20/25 years down the line, this film will always instil her with a sense of pride!

This writer witnessed an exclusive closed-door screening of the film earlier this week. The detailed review will appear on its worldwide theatrical release, on January 30, 2004.

Send us your feedback on this feature


**** I thought SAAYA was very much VISUALLY APPEALING with GOOD MUSIC>>

No doubt, POOJA is talented
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------


Top
 Profile  
 
 Post subject:
PostPosted: Wed Jan 14, 2004 9:24 pm 
Offline

Joined: Sat Aug 24, 2002 11:19 am
Posts: 149
Location: Toronto, Canada
arsh wrote:
**** I thought SAAYA was very much VISUALLY APPEALING with GOOD MUSIC>>

No doubt, POOJA is talented

Agreed Arsh!! Saaya I thought was one of the better flicks of 2003...I love the whole romantic, spiritual genre and Paap seems like its a big step in the right direction.

Can't wait to see that and Ek Hasina Thi!!


Top
 Profile  
 
 Post subject:
PostPosted: Thu Jan 29, 2004 4:32 pm 
Offline

Joined: Mon Dec 03, 2001 5:53 pm
Posts: 14989
Paap: Not sinful enough!

Sukanya Verma | January 29, 2004 02:11 IST


You are alone in the middle of the vast Spiti Valley.
It is hard to breathe thanks to depleting oxygen levels.
Not a single sound except the whisper of your heartbeat.
Not a soul in sight.

No, I am not trying to hypnotise you. I am taking you inside Pooja Bhatt's Paap.

Bhatt's directorial debut is set in the solitude of Spiti, Himachal Pradesh. The loneliness of this isolated place reflects the character of Kaaya (Udita Goswami).

Brought up under the watchful eye of her strict father (Dr Mohan Agashe) and the warm Lama Noburu (Denzil Smith) of the nearby Buddhist monastery, Kaaya is forbidden to dream and desire.

But Kaaya does just that. When not having leisurely baths in the river or walking naked feet in the lush fields, Kaaya secretly writes love poems waiting for that special someone.

Lama Noburu assigns Kaaya the task of bringing the six-year-old Llhamo (Madan Bhiku) from Delhi. Llhamo is no ordinary soul. Apparently he is the reincarnation of some great monk.

Kaaya and Llhamo meet police officer Shiven (John Abraham), when the little boy witnesses a murder. As the case turns complicated, Shiven decides to take them back to Spiti. He gets severely injured in the process. Kaaya and the monks nurse him back to health.

Fascinated by Shiven, Kaaya begins fantasising about him. Her fantasy results in the clash of two points of view.

Point of view # 1: Shiven is all for the Kal Ho Naa Ho motto: live every moment; he also looks down on the rebirth theory.

Point of view # 2: Kaaya's father is the desi Alfred Molina (of Chocolat). He believes abstinence is the key to a better life in future births.

Kaaya has to choose between the man she desires and the path her father has chosen for her. While Kaaya makes up her mind, I'll tell you the little pros and many cons of the film.

The entire sequence which shows Shiven drive to Spiti is unnecessarily dramatic. The classical-rock fusion number, Garaj baras plays furiously in the background. The timing couldn't have been worse. He is badly injured, yet insists on behaving like a martyr. The whole world can notice his injury except Kaaya. All this time you wonder: Why?

Paap is a love story of the earthy (read erotic) kind. The attraction between Shiven and Kaaya is purely physical. For someone with such a puritanical upbringing, Kaaya's fantasies are incredibly tantalising.

Newcomer Udita Goswami looks stunning. But her exotic looks don't have the air of a simple small town girl. She looks too groomed. Her emotive abilities are restricted to clueless gaping and looking scared. Her object of affection in Paap, John Abraham furrows his forehead, rolls his eyes upwards, snarls crazily and roams shirtless in Spiti. Great physique. Now can we have some acting, please?

Also, why does every character in Paap talk in different volume levels? John Abraham murmurs. Udita Goswami screeches. Dr Mohan Agashe shrieks.

Now for the goodies: Anshuman Mahaley has shot the film beautifully. The background score by Music Mushrooms is impressive. The song Mann ki lagan is exceptionally melodious. Niranjan Iyengar's dialogues are smart, poetic and eloquent.

The young actor Madan Bhiku is a revelation. He is a complete natural. His innocent little face and big eyes convey a range of emotions.

Frankly, I had expected something more hard-hitting from this articulate actress turned filmmaker. Although Bhatt maintains an intense mood throughout, Paap isn't sinful enough.

rediff


Top
 Profile  
 
 Post subject:
PostPosted: Thu Jan 29, 2004 6:13 pm 
Offline

Joined: Sat Jun 22, 2002 3:05 am
Posts: 176
Quote:
Kaaya and Llhamo meet police officer Shiven (John Abraham), when the little boy witnesses a murder. As the case turns complicated, Shiven decides to take them back to Spiti. He gets severely injured in the process. Kaaya and the monks nurse him back to health.


Darn, but that sounds just like Harrison Ford's Witness.


Top
 Profile  
 
 Post subject:
PostPosted: Thu Jan 29, 2004 6:44 pm 
Offline

Joined: Mon Dec 03, 2001 5:53 pm
Posts: 14989
What else, should we EXPECT from BHATT's Clan, RECYCLING with CLASS!! :nopity:


Top
 Profile  
 
 Post subject:
PostPosted: Fri Jan 30, 2004 4:16 pm 
Offline

Joined: Mon Dec 03, 2001 5:53 pm
Posts: 14989
Now TARAN's TRADE review:

Paap

By Taran Adarsh

Many a times, producers bow down to market diktats and end up making films that are ancient history soon after they've hit the marquee. Their 'life' at the box-office is short-lived primarily because the passion to create something exciting is missing.

But you do come across that rare film which lingers in your memory and remains etched even after months have elapsed.

Inspired by director Peter Weir's immensely successful flick WITNESS [1985; Harrison Ford, Kelly McGillis], Pooja Bhatt's PAAP [produced by Shreya Creations P. Ltd. and Fish Eye Network P. Ltd.] is one such film that stays with you!

When the Rimpoche – the religious head from a serene monastery in Spiti, Himachal Pradesh – gets a vision about his Master's reincarnation in New Delhi as a six-year-old boy, it is left to a young girl from the town, Kaya [Udita Goswami], to bring the six-year-old child Llahmo [Madan] back to the monastery.

Although Kaya has been brought up in the quiet but disciplined environment of Spiti and has been conditioned by her stern father [Dr. Mohan Agashe] to believe that denial is the only route to higher truth, her heart wanders into territories common for a girl her age. She yearns for love and waits for its arrival during her private moments.

As fate would have it, Llahmo gets involved with the murder of a key police officer in New Delhi and becomes a key witness to the case. Investigating the murder is a righteous police officer Shiven [John Abraham]. Although Kaya resents his philosophy and clashes with him on several occasions owing to his views on reincarnation, sacrifice and higher truth, she finds herself strangely drawn towards him.

The murder case complicates further till there is no option for Shiven except to reach Kaya and Llahmo to their own safe surroundings. Injured in the process of this escape, he still manages to take them safely to Spiti. His injury is serious and he is forced by the elders and Kaya to stay in the village amongst the monks, a village life, a bitter father and his growing attraction for Kaya till he is healed.

During his stay he manages to evoke several suppressed feelings in Kaya and this causes concern to her father, who has already chalked a path that she must take.

As the danger from the city, in the form of the actual murderers, comes closer and closer to Spiti, threatening to break the silence in the valley with blood and gunshots, Kaya has to make up her mind whether she wants to follow her heart that will give her happiness in this birth or follow a path of sacrifice to secure joy in her future births.

In an era where most writers/directors focus on gimmicks while the story takes a complete backseat, PAAP stands out as an exception. Here's a story that's refreshingly different from what you've viewed so far. The focus is clearly on content, not gimmicks.

PAAP marks Pooja's directorial debut and although on new turf, she has created an engrossing fare that is visually stunning and thematically moving. The film is extremely successful in drawing the viewer into its world.

Tackling a serious theme in her very first film must've been nothing short of a challenge. And Pooja emerges trumps. The deft handling of the story manages to keep the viewer enticed for the next two hours [12 reels].

However, the film is not without its share of flaws –
One, the story moves at a leisurely pace. Given the theme of the film [thriller], the goings-on should be unfurling at a rapid pace. Besides, the way the story is narrated gives it a very urban feel.

From the scripting point of view, the villain's track should've been better thought of. The emergence of the villains in the climax looks contrived and the sudden change of heart of the lone surviving villain towards the end is hard to absorb.

Brilliantly shot by cinematographer Anshuman Mahaley [the locales of Spiti cannot be described in mere words!] and efficiently edited by Akiv Ali, PAAP also boasts of brilliantly-penned dialogues that are soaked in emotions [Niranjan Iyengar], a well-Indianised screenplay [Mahesh Bhatt] and scintillating performances by the entire cast.

John Abraham takes giant strides as an actor. The kind of maturity he reflects in his fourth film is rare. Dr. Mohan Agashe is superb [the confrontation scene between John and Agashe is outstanding]. Denzil Smith is first-rate, while Sandeep Mehta is an actor to watch. Child artiste Madan Bhiku is next to perfect. Gulshan Grover and Anahita Uberoi are efficient.

However, it is new-find Udita Goswami who surprises you with a performance that is sure to find a place in all award nominations next year. You can't help but put your two hands together for this bravura performance!

The music gels well with the narrative. 'Intezaar' [music: Anu Malik; singer: Anuradha Paudwal] and 'Lagan' [music: Shahi; singer: Rahat Fateh Ali Khan] are the pick of the lot.

On the whole, PAAP satiates the appetite of the urban audience looking for a story-based fare. At the box-office, the film should find patronage at multiplexes of metros mainly. For those looking for typical Bollywood masala fare, PAAP has very little to offer. Also, lack of aggressive promotion may curtail its business to an extent!

Rating:- * * ½.


Top
 Profile  
 
 Post subject:
PostPosted: Fri Jan 30, 2004 4:37 pm 
Offline

Joined: Sun Dec 16, 2001 7:27 pm
Posts: 6146
arsh wrote:
'Paap' exciting!

By Taran Adarsh, January 14th, 2004 - 0930 hrs IST


But you do come across that rare film which lingers in your memory and remains etched even after months have elapsed. Pooja Bhatt's PAAP [produced by Shreya Creations P. Ltd. and Fisheye Network P. Ltd.] is one such film that stays with you!

All in all, PAAP is one film that is sure to be noticed. Noticed for its performances. Noticed for the story, screenplay and dialogues. Noticed for the strong visual appeal… But more than anything else, it'll be noticed for the transition of a talented actress to a good producer to a sensitive storyteller [director].

When Pooja looks back at her career, may be 20/25 years down the line, this film will always instil her with a sense of pride!

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Paap has mostly received glowing reviews. Now, contrast this with First Day First Show Audience Reaction:

http://www.indiafm.com/broadband/04/jan ... ndex.shtml

By IndiaFM News Bureau, January 30th, 2004 - 1930 hrs IST

As the First Day First Show got over at the Metro Cinema, we got one word responses from the disappointed audience which are listed as follows

Boring...
Faaltu...
Bhankas...
Total Bakwaas...
Hopeless...
It Sucks...
Pathetic...

A guy asked our crew “What is Paap in this movie?” Maybe, the promos have misled the audience.

As another viewer puts in, ”It is a Paap to watch this movie”.

WHAT WENT WRONG??

Rana


Top
 Profile  
 
 Post subject:
PostPosted: Fri Jan 30, 2004 4:45 pm 
Offline

Joined: Mon Dec 03, 2001 5:53 pm
Posts: 14989
KIND OF AUDIENCE WHO WATCHED THE FILM? LOL>>

THEY WERE EXPECTING PAAP LADDEN STEAMY SCENES YAAR??


Top
 Profile  
 
 Post subject:
PostPosted: Fri Jan 30, 2004 10:19 pm 
Offline

Joined: Mon Dec 03, 2001 5:53 pm
Posts: 14989
'Paap' - Sinful Waste Of Time
By Prema K. ©2004 Bollyvista.com


Credits
Producer/s: Fish Eye Network
Director: Pooja Bhatt
Cast: John Abraham, Udita Gowswami (Introducing), Mohan Agashe, Master. Madan, Gulshan Grover, Anahita Uberoi, Denzil Smith, Anupam Shyam
Music: Anu Malik, Shahi, Ali Azmat
Lyrics: Sayeed Quadri, Amjad Islam Amjad, Sabir Zafar & Ali Azmat


Buy the DVD here
The only things in favour of 'Paap' are its brilliant cinematography and superb locales. This is what made me endure this 2-hour frame-to-frame boring remake of 'Witness'.

Somewhere the director seems to be confused. It starts off as a sort of thriller but tapers down to an insipid love story where emotions are expressed through the female protagonist, Kaya's (model-turned-actress Udita Goswami), erotic imagination.

At times one also has to put up with long sermons (please spare us!) on the teachings of Buddha. The one in the climax is a howler. So if this film is trying to inculcate spiritual values in the audience then it fails at that level too. It's too superficial to make any impact.

The story- Sitting in his monastery in the Himalayas, an elderly Lama gets a vision indicating the rebirth of his teacher in Delhi. He calls upon Kaya to locate the child and bring him to the monastery. What is the pretty, designer clad Kaya doing in the mountains? Her father has also planned her life for her. In some time she too will join the monastery. Wonder which father would force his only child to lead a life of celibacy? Don't ask why! Watch the film to find out!

On their way back, the child is witness to the murder of a police officer at the airport. Police Officer Shiven (John Abraham who looks, talks, and walks like a model in his designer clothes) is in charge of the case. When he realizes that some police officers are involved in the murder, he realizes it's time to flee. After a lot of unwanted drama and action he reaches the Himalayas with Kaya and the child. Soon its time for love to blossom!

Performances, especially that of the main leads, leave a lot to be desired. While model-turned-actress, Udita, emotes better than her male counterpart (which is not saying much), John is still under the impression that muscle flexing and flaunting designer clothes on a gym toned body is all there is to acting. In comparison to his debut film, one can only say that he has mastered the art of contorting his facial muscles and raves at rants at the slightest provocation. This is probably his idea of emoting. His voice being dubbed does not help either. Newcomer Udita is attractive in her own way but lacks sex appeal. She also seems to be in serious need of a nose job or at least good makeup to conceal her flaw. A talented actor like Gulshan Grover is wasted in this flick. One can go on and on about the flaws in the film but it seems like a waste of time!

** (TWO STARS)

*poor; **average; ***good; ****very good; *****excellent


Top
 Profile  
 
 Post subject:
PostPosted: Fri Feb 06, 2004 6:40 pm 
Offline

Joined: Mon Dec 03, 2001 5:53 pm
Posts: 14989
SCREEN:

Not too sinful

Sukanya Venkatraghavan



Cast and Credits


Producer& Director
Fisheye Network and Shreya Creations, Pooja Bhatt
Music
Anu Malik
Cast
John Abraham, Udita Goswami







he writes poetry in free verse. And would like to be a free spirit. But daddy dearest will have none of it because he believes walking down the spiritual path would be a far better option for Kaya than taking long walks by herself. So the poor girl does all her stuff in secret. Like looking at herself in the mirror, and taking semi nude dips in freezing waters, not to mention croon about prince charming. So far, not so bad. Then the girl gets sent to Delhi to bring back a Lama reborn who happens to be witness to a murder. Temporarily cut to a hasty version of Witness. John Abraham makes an entry as the cop keen to nab the nasty killer. To cut a long story short, the three are forced to flee the scene and Shiven with a bullet in the side manages a crazy drive back to Manali. Kaya plays nurse to him under the watchful eye of grouchy dad (Mohan Agashe) and in due course she has some unabashed fantasies about the virile cop. Which we are supposed to interpret as love .Pop smells a rat and reminds Kaya that she will be cooling her heels (and desires) in a monastery so she can put a lid on her feelings. He also admonishes Shiven for being ’ungrateful’. A few rambling scenes, some indifferent action and karmic speeches later, pop and the cop resolve their differences and leave the poor girl to decide whether she will choose love over celibacy.

Pooja Bhatt’s directorial debut is interesting in its thematic quality but disappoints in execution. What could have been an interesting tug of war between the spiritual and the material (in this case physical) becomes merely a horizontal graph of tepid emotions. There is practically no interaction verbal or physical (save for the poetry reading session) between the two protagonists to suggest deep feelings on either side. John Abraham is okay in the lighter moments but tends to overplay in the crucial ones. Udita Goswami catwalks through most of the proceedings and tries her level best to look interested. Cinematography is exceptional and the music spellbinding, but Paap is reduced to a bunch of breathtaking calendar shots with little emotional depth.





--------------------------------------------------------------------------------


Top
 Profile  
 
Display posts from previous:  Sort by  
Post new topic Reply to topic  [ 10 posts ] 

All times are UTC


Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 4 guests


You cannot post new topics in this forum
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
You cannot edit your posts in this forum
You cannot delete your posts in this forum

Search for:
Jump to:  
Powered by phpBB® Forum Software © phpBB Group