It is currently Mon Nov 17, 2025 1:22 pm

All times are UTC




Post new topic Reply to topic  [ 8 posts ] 
Author Message
PostPosted: Fri Jan 16, 2004 9:14 pm 
Offline

Joined: Wed Dec 05, 2001 3:16 am
Posts: 4259
http://sify.com/movies/tamil/review.php?cid=2429

Virumaandi

Director
Kamalhassan

Producer
S. Chandrahassan, Kamalhassan

Cinematographer
Keshav Prakash

Music
Ilayaraaja

Cast
Kamalhassan, Abhirami, Napoleon, Nassar, Pasupathy, Rohini


By Moviebuzz

Kamalhassan’s Virumaandi is a vital, sardonic and disturbing brave attempt at good cinema with a provocative message. It is an eloquent argument against capital punishment without excusing the killer for his crimes.

At the moral centre of the film are two men - Virumaandi (Kamalhassan) who is waiting for death sentence for crimes that he has not committed and Kothala Thevar (Pasupathy) serving life imprisonment after killing many innocents. Maybe there is redemption yet as Angela Kathamuthu (Rohini) a documentary film-maker and a fierce critic of capital punishment comes to the central jail in Chennai to make a TV documentary on this sensitive issue.

The two protagonists are initially reluctant to speak but later confess their respective side of the same story and Angela is able to bond with them more out of duress than choice and is slowly sucked in as the videotaping turns dangerous! Kamalhassan weaves together real life incidents; fantasy and imagination with a chilling motif - people are not what they appear to be. The background details are perfectly worked out though there are rankling echoes of Hollywood anti- death penalty movies like Kevin Spacey’s The Life Of David Gale and Sean Penn’s Dead Man Walking .

Virumaandi is a film both told in the present and past which makes it slow paced. The film at times looks arty with its documentary approach to story telling. The double narrative with typical Theni dialect is confusing at times. Virumaandi is a brave man, a lovable rascal for the villagers of Chinnakkolarpatti in Theni district. He is emotional about his friends and will do anything for their sake including taking part in jallikattu (bull fighting). His biggest supporter is Supputhayi, his grandmother who always reminds him that he owns the most fertile pieces of land in the village as it has “Liquid Gold”- water.

A local chieftain and influential man Kothala Thevar (Pasuathy) eyes Virumaandi’s property though they are good friends. Kothala’s niece, Annalachumi (Abhirami) is a bold, aggressive girl who travels in a moped and runs her own poultry farm and rears Sorimuttu, a jallikattu bull, whom Virumaandi defeats and she falls in love with him! In Kothala’s fight against another chieftain Nallamanicker (Napolean), Virumaandi supports him to the hilt. Slowly but tactfully Kothala frames Virumaandi but Annalachumi helps him and they elope to a nearby village and get married.

But Kothala traces them with the help of a corrupt police officer Paykamman (Shanmugham) and she is brought back to be humiliated and get forcefully married to Kottaichami. But Annalachumi commits suicide in disgrace and Virumaandi is now on a rampage and is helped by Nallamanickar. But in a twist of events Virumaandi is caught and sentenced to death for killing 24 innocent people and abducting and raping Annalachumi. But Kothala who surrenders is only given a life imprisonment. Now Angela unspools her tape as the film moves to a bloody climax in the jail.

Kamal unfortunately is unable to dovetail the film to its logical conclusion. What starts off as a full-throttle premise peters out to a lame finale. However topline work is elicited from cinematographer Keshav Prakash and art director Prabhakaran who were able to give a local flavour and smell of Theni village to Campa Cola grounds in Chennai especially in the Jallikattu scenes. Ilayaraja’s music is melodious.

Pasupathy as Kothala Thevar is menacing and has given villainy a new meaning. Naseer and Napoleon are wasted in insignificant roles while Rohini does a superb cameo. Abhirami brings compassion and conviction to the role of Annalachumi. She is brilliant and is able to match up to the hero in those steamy romantic scenes. And finally at the epicentre of the film is Kamalahassan. As the tale heats up the versatile actor comes alive and captures the zest and passion called by the script. Be it his flawless comic timing or his denouement in the prison, he is astounding.

For the first time in Indian mainstream cinema a director has made a film, which consists of different narratives by two central characters connected by one sole incident. Sometimes you will see the same scene that will make sense as the story unfolds. On the downside there is too much blood and gore and violence against women, which could have been avoided. Still Virumaandi is a cut above the common place.

Verdict: Class Act






Maybe the documentary filmmaker character is inspired from Teen Deewarein???




Edited By DragunR2 on 1074287758


Top
 Profile  
 
 Post subject:
PostPosted: Fri Jan 16, 2004 11:40 pm 
Offline

Joined: Mon Dec 03, 2001 5:53 pm
Posts: 14989
I saw this at rediff:

Reviews

Virumaandi is Kamal all the way!

Shobha Warrier | January 16, 2004 13:25 IST


While announcing the shooting of the film Virumaandi, then known as Sandiyar, Kamal Haasan said he wanted to convey the message of non-violence through a violent film.

And Virumaandi is an extremely violent film, full of blood, gory deaths, mutilated bodies, abusive language and what not. But the film does convey the intended message. The film is gripping and very well executed. In fact, I am willing to see it again to enjoy some of the finer nuances of the film. The film is a spectacle.


What is quite interesting about this directorial venture of Kamal Haasan is the way it is narrated. The story of Virumaandi is told in flashback through the eyes of two people, Virumaandi (Kamal Haasan) and Kotthalathevar (Pasupathy), both of whom are in the Chennai Central Jail.

The story unravels with Angela Katthamuthu (Rohini), a lawyer with a doctorate in the study of human rights. He works for a human rights organisation and visits the jail to interview the inmates on death row. Angela is a strong opponent of capital punishment.

Kotthalathevar first tells his version of the story in which Virumaandi is the villain and responsible for the killings of nearly two dozen innocents in a village in Theni district. He tells Angela that Virumaandi deserves to be exterminated from the face of the earth.

But when she questions Virumaandi, she gets a different version in which the villain is Kotthalathevar himself.

That is the true version. Virumaandi is to be executed for a crime he did not commit.

Kotthalathevar, who had an eye on Virumaandi's land -- where water flows freely -- first agrees to give his niece Annalachumi's (Abhirami) hand to Virumaandi in marriage. Both fall in love, but then Kotthalathevar changes his mind.

Nallamanaiker, (Napoleon), the kind-hearted head of the village, is unable to do anything in the face of Kotthalathevar's mounting villainy. Kotthalathevar, in turn, manages to place under his own control almost the entire corrupt police force. When Kotthalathevar brutally massacres a large number of villagers, a helpless Naiker is forced to look on. Kotthalathevar then uses animal cunning to place the blame squarely on Virumaandi.

Meanwhile, Virumaandi and Annalachumi elope and get married. Unfortunately, she is kidnapped back to the village by Kotthalathevar, who gifts her to his henchman. A humiliated Annlachumi commits suicide. Virumaandi has one more case foisted on him, of raping Annalachumi and thus being responsible for her death. When lured by money, the priest who marries them off in a temple also turns against Virumaandi.

Nallamanaiker helps Virumaandi escape. But in the process, he gets murdered by Kotthalathevar. That brings Kotthalathevar to jail. Now, both of them are languishing in jail, with Kotthalathevar enjoying his jail term in the lap of luxury, thanks to his money and connections. And Virumaandi, the innocent victim, waits for death.

Kamal Haasan the director has done a marvellous job in showing the same incidents from two different points of view.

The story that starts with Angela videotaping some of the inmates ends at the same place, after a lot of action and gripping tension. After Angela's cameraman tapes the corrupt jail official instructing some of his men to knock off the honest jailer (Nasser), both Angela and the cameraman are on the run inside the jail. A riot in the jail is followed by more violence and more deaths. But in the gripping finale, Angela escapes with the help of Virumaandi.

The director has used the clashes that used to take place till recently in the southern districts of Tamil Nadu as reference points, and shown them realistically onscreen. To his credit, perhaps as a precautionary measure, he has not taken the sides of any community, as was feared by the leader of Puthiya Thamizhagam, Dr Krishnaswamy.

Though it is said that National Award winner Venu is the best cinematographer India has to shoot crowd scenes, one feels Keshav Prakash, assistant to Ravi K Chandran in Kamal Haasan's currently shelved project, Marudanayakam, is as good, or even better.

With more than a dozen people in each frame, Virumaandi is not an easy film to make, but both the director and the cinematographer have done an amazing job.

One jarring note in the film is Kamal's fair skin, which stood out like a sore thumb. Among all the other dark-skinned villagers, his extremely fair skin did not go well. Perhaps he should have darkened his skin to look like the rest of them.

The film does remind one of Kamal's earlier Thevar Magan, but technically and in terms of the quality of execution, Virumaandi has moved ahead. When Bharathan (director of Thevar Magan) was alive, he was described as the best maker of violent films. No one could match the violent vibrations palpable in his films.

Now, with Virumaandi, Kamal Haasan has gone a step ahead.

Without any hesitation, one can aver that Kamal Haasan as the director and screenplay writer of Virumaandi has done a great job. But the same cannot be said of Kamal Haasan the actor. There are many other performers who have done better jobs than Kamal Haasan in the film.

For example, the two female characters, Annalachumi and Angela (beautifully portrayed by Abhirami and Rohini), steal the show with their understated but strikingly confident performances. If Pasupathy as Kotthalathevar is menacingly different, Napoleon as Nallamanaiker has a quiet dignity about him.

Virumaandi is definitely a Kamal film but this one belongs to Kamal the director, not Kamal the actor.


** whom he is SMOOCHING this time?






Image




Edited By arsh on 1074296482


Top
 Profile  
 
 Post subject:
PostPosted: Sat Jan 17, 2004 12:24 am 
Offline

Joined: Sun Dec 08, 2002 4:29 pm
Posts: 672
Location: NY
Virumaandi is on my must see list. I read some where that Kamal Hassan's company is releasing the Virumaandi dvd. Anbody know more about this? Does this mean that Ayngaran or Tamilini won't get the dvd rights?
:hmm: :oo:


Top
 Profile  
 
 Post subject:
PostPosted: Sat Jan 17, 2004 12:57 am 
Offline

Joined: Wed Dec 05, 2001 3:16 am
Posts: 4259
arsh wrote:
** whom he is SMOOCHING this time?

The girl in the middle, Abhirami. Let's see how long Kamal can pair himself with heroines 20 years younger! :baaa:

Image


Quote:
Virumaandi is on my must see list. I read some where that Kamal Hassan's company is releasing the Virumaandi dvd. Anbody know more about this? Does this mean that Ayngaran or Tamilini won't get the dvd rights?


I read something in which Kamal or a Raajkamal rep said "we" will be releasing the DVD, which is pretty vague. BMD released 3 Kamal films so far, Hey Ram (a Raajkamal production), Thenali, and Anbe Sivam ("presented" by Kamal) so maybe they'll do it, but this is really Sunny's department :) It is rare that Tamil movies are released on DVD by the studio themselves, except for Pyramid produced films.

It was supposed to be released in India on Pongal, which is January 13 or 14. Maybe it was delayed.




Edited By DragunR2 on 1074301233


Top
 Profile  
 
 Post subject:
PostPosted: Sat Jan 17, 2004 2:14 am 
Offline
User avatar

Joined: Mon Dec 03, 2001 11:01 pm
Posts: 2070
Location: Toronto, Canada
This, I must see.

Image


Top
 Profile  
 
 Post subject:
PostPosted: Sat Jan 17, 2004 3:05 am 
Offline

Joined: Wed Dec 05, 2001 3:16 am
Posts: 4259
arsh wrote:
The film does remind one of Kamal's earlier Thevar Magan, but technically and in terms of the quality of execution, Virumaandi has moved ahead. When Bharathan (director of Thevar Magan) was alive, he was described as the best maker of violent films. No one could match the violent vibrations palpable in his films.

FYI, Thevar Magan was remade in Hindi as Virasat.


Top
 Profile  
 
 Post subject:
PostPosted: Sun Jan 18, 2004 4:41 pm 
Offline

Joined: Thu Dec 25, 2003 7:59 pm
Posts: 159
and Bharathan only directed half of the movie, and left the project due to kamal.


Top
 Profile  
 
 Post subject:
PostPosted: Fri Jan 23, 2004 11:28 pm 
Offline

Joined: Wed Dec 05, 2001 3:16 am
Posts: 4259
Kuttappan wrote:
and Bharathan only directed half of the movie, and left the project due to kamal.

Who directed the rest of it?

Has Virumaandi been released anywhere in the US or UK? It isn't playing in Dallas.


Top
 Profile  
 
Display posts from previous:  Sort by  
Post new topic Reply to topic  [ 8 posts ] 

All times are UTC


Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 6 guests


You cannot post new topics in this forum
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
You cannot edit your posts in this forum
You cannot delete your posts in this forum

Search for:
Jump to:  
Powered by phpBB® Forum Software © phpBB Group