:angry: well exuse me im not trying to make a point that MDK does not sux or is the best movie ever i am just posting box office reviews if that is a crime just say so :vsneaky:

[Duh _rb_ again Let them movie be No#1 in the US/UK BO charts]

UK...Charts! Spoiled BRITS!!! Sucks!! HTHS, HKKN, YHJ, YRHPK, MYKSH, and tons of other MINDLESS shitties, climbing UK charts, not to mention, honorablly..YAADEIN(that made Ghaii, recovered all his DOOBA PAISA from UK, BO)

So climbing UK charts??? does not COUNT/ACCOUNT/SPEAKS..for any film IMHO! I dont care..period! UK chart status!

Did I , at any time say that ur Post was a "crime" I am trying to argue against what you had posted and surely argue karna PAAP nahi hai Agar hai toh maine Paap kiya hai.. aur hazaar baar Paap karoonga .... (Salim-Javed pls rest in peace )

Duh _rb_ again Let them movie be No#1 in the US/UK BO charts... Uk/USA/Canada ?...[/quote][/quote]
:vangry: well it was the quote above that made it seem so :nervous: :tounge: :gob: :doze: :alien: :alien:

Sknath-

I see that your so caught up in defending yourself that you forgot to write how many times you saw the movie, once, twice? Wait....you didnt.

Think about this, for two people (Arsh,Sknath) who did not see the movie, not one frame or scene, you two sure did post ALOT in the thread that was meant for talking about the movie (From Arsh's copying and pasting tirade, to your downplaying of people's opinion who happen to ACTUALLY see the movie). I am not like you, not going to "warn" you or tell you what to do, I am not the administrator, I actually could care less, but think about that point.



I think a hit or a flop is based on how much money one would recover from the film. From your stand point, what your saying is that it could make a million DOLLARS in the U.S., U.K., Canada but because it didnt make a million RUPEES its not a hit? Is that correct according to you?

So the film is making money in the UK, its topping the charts, and now the charts dont matter. Remember that when Kaante is up there, and see what will be said. :plain:

A Letter From The Director: Kunal Kohli



Edited By Naven on Aug. 13 2002 at 17:52

Naven You are right, I didnt see the movie for once and dont plan to do so in the near future also .. As to why arsh bhai and myself have posted a lot.. its from past experiences.. (na Tum Jano Na Hum, AMALL, etc etc..) which i had the misfortune of watching
Now after those movies, and knowing what the plot of MDK is, do you expect me ( or for that matter any sensible person) to relaize what kinda story that might be other than the usual clichéd stuff ?
My conversations with _rb_ is in a lighter vein and so also with arsh and I think both of them understand that. As for you.. I guess I see no hope for you..
Like i said, if you think Na Tum Jano Na Hum was a hit, so be it.. If you think MDK is a hit , so be it

Of course, money is indeed a factor for declaring a movie hot for a flop ( or for that matter the only reason it is declared a hit). But pray tell me is MDK in any way an ARTISTIC success also ? I doubt it, and it will be judged from the awards which are given out to the films as well as by viewers and critics... Unless u expecting something quite spectacular, I doubt if this film is gonna get any mention at all (sans for Rani Mukherjee).

& By the way if you didnt know, I may not like Predator's Mum and his posts's... but I think he is the right person for ya and ur posts and ur Hrithik Obsession

*ps :- I am not a Shahrukh Fan in any way..and I went to see Devdas for Madhuri and the sets and the songs and her dialogues (PERIOD... lest some folks address me here as DEVDAS buff )

I have no hopes for Kaante.. I leave that to my good friend Faddy

Love scores over friendship!!

**** baki aap khud samajhdar haen!


http://www.rediff.com/entertai/2002/aug/13box.htm

BTW! in my understanding HTHS got a BETTER opening in Uk, than MDK??? can somebody, subsantiate this statement, or decline? with FIGURES!! Sach, hona! shart hai! :vsneaky:

BTW!***Did some body c this?
"one movie wonder?"
http://www.indolink.com/Forum/Bollywood ... 818.html(i am not sure, abt real source, but DAMn it is right on!)
:vsneaky:



Edited By arsh on Aug. 13 2002 at 20:51

what is HTHS??? of course i saw that did u see this

http://www.indiafm.com/views/2002/mdk.shtml
http://www.rediff.com/entertai/2002/aug/14reader.htm
:alien:

Ganti! Yaar! I thought, every body knew! HTHS!

Hum Tumhare haen sanam!!?? did i abbreviate it wrong?

HTHS..was in UK charts for LONG TIME, made a lot of money!
so i was wondering, If one of DUGU fan! give us FIGURES , from UK, BO, for MDK! and SRK fan will provide HTHS figures from UK BO too, we can compare this statement..lol, mullah to mullah!Pound to POUND!!

If money is that really matters 9Paisa bolta hai?)and MAKE A HIT and GOOD/QUALITY film!? kiya bolta tou? :vsneaky: Buttt!! that will make YAADEIN>.biggest hit of HRITHIK>>the HATTRICK!

http://www.screendaily.com/story.asp?st ... =sanam&s=3

The most impressive of this week’s debutantes was Eros International’s latest Bollywood release, Hum Tumhare Hain Sanam. The romantic drama grossed a mighty $354,191 (£242,975) off just 28 sites – a site average of $12,650 – and landed in seventh position. The film, which stars Shahrukh Khan, Madhuri Dixit and Atul Agnihotri, is the highest opening ever in the UK for a Bollywood film handled by Eros and the third highest Bollywood opening ever in the country, behind last year’s K3G ($690,022 from 41 sites) and 2000’s Mohabbatein ($359,137 from 26 sites) – both distributed by Yash Raj Films.

sorry to say this but......

a very very poor film........

ok songs are great BUT........

the same old gimmicks again and again!!!!

YRF pls note - u must come up with fresh ideas!!!

YRF u cannot take 5/6 films and put them into one time and time again and get away with it - PEOPLE HAVE CAUGHT ON!!!!!

PLEASE ADVISE YRF!!!!!!





D: D: D:

honestly, i wouldn't mind if yrf just stuck to sappy family/love stories. they have done a great job with these movies in the past, even though their last few releases weren't the best. the type of movies that yrf puts out time and time again seem to appeal to many viewers, especially the non-hindi speaking audience. i know many non-hindi speaking people who love the types of films that yrf makes, and have never heard of or want to see movies like "satya" or "kaante." in short, yrf has done a lot for hindi movies outside of india, and judging from the success of their past blockbusters, even indians love them too. so i say lets leave them alone and pray that they come up with something new in the sappy family/love story department, and pester the rest of bollywood to come up with unique and innovative movies.

Theon..Vijay,Lamhe,WAQT werent sappy family dramas (they were fresh and unique).. In fact LAMHE was miles ahead of the rest of the competition that year. Unfortunately it lost out as IGNORANT folks here couldnt understand that film ... Tell me why would a filmmaker like to take risks when he knows that audiences (like the ones who pamper these immature films like MDK etc.) will ditch it in the first weekend itself ?

[a very very poor film.......]????? ???

ooey!! Ranjeetaya! Yaara!!!kaidi?

MDK? ya fir HTHS!!??
??? :vsneaky:



Edited By arsh on Aug. 14 2002 at 17:50

i was referring to the post ddlj era