It is currently Mon Nov 17, 2025 5:56 pm

All times are UTC




Post new topic Reply to topic  [ 3 posts ] 
Author Message
PostPosted: Thu Aug 28, 2003 9:23 pm 
Offline

Joined: Mon Dec 03, 2001 5:53 pm
Posts: 14989
Sneak preview: Gangaajal

Deepa Gumaste | August 28, 2003 23:07 IST


Positives:

Ajay Devgan's imposing act. Yet again he proves why he is the smartest actor of his generation by picking up an author-backed role and making the most of it.
Mukesh Tiwari. Five years after he made his debut, this brilliant actor finally gets a role worthy of his talent and executes it with passion.
Wayne Sharpe's soulful background score. When was the last time you even noticed background music in a Hindi film?
Arvind K's polished camerawork. No, there's no Switzerland, or Shimla even, but the cinematography makes the sleepy town of Wai in Maharashtra look truly beautiful.
Crisp dialogues which extol the idealism that is so conspicuous by its absence in everyday life.
Negatives:

A serious Shool (directed by E Niwas, starring Manoj Bajpai) hangover. Yet another honest cop struggling to surmount the corrupt milieu he lives and works in.
Gracy Singh's character. Apart from getting second billing in the credits, she has nothing to write home about. She does not even attempt to leave a mark on the proceedings.
The mandatory item number, which the writer-filmmaker may claim is justified. Some of us are sick to death of watching inadequately dressed women dancing before leacherous men.
The plot meanders in the second half and the director loses his grip on the proceedings.
The climax has a déjà vu feel and reminds you of Jha's own Mrityudand.
You may not find too many things you have not seen before. But it is still heartening to watch good triumph over evil yet again, especially since you only get to see it in the movies these days!

Look out for the full review of Gangaajal in a few hours!


REDIFF


Top
 Profile  
 
 Post subject:
PostPosted: Fri Aug 29, 2003 3:15 pm 
Offline

Joined: Mon Dec 03, 2001 5:53 pm
Posts: 14989
Full review:

Another ace for Ajay!

Deepa Gumaste | August 29, 2003 11:18 IST


Twenty years after Govind Nihalani made Ardh Satya, conscientious cops in Hindi cinema are still trying to overcome the same hurdles Anant Welankar stumbled against.

There is deep-rooted corruption in the police force, there are politicians. And there are feudal lords (often you cannot tell the difference). And their wayward gun-totting sons who have a penchant for terrorising the neighbourhood. And the honest police officer who gets stick from both ends.




Prakash Jha's Gangaajal (co-produced by Manmohan Shetty who also produced Ardh Satya), is no different. It follows in the footsteps of E Niwas' Shool, one of the better Hindi films about the predicament of an upright cop who takes on a degenerate system.

Jha makes things a little easier for himself by not making his hero a low-ranking inspector. Instead, Amit Kumar (Ajay Devgan) is the new Superintendent of Police in charge of a notorious district in Bihar called Tejpur.

Tejpur, which lies on the banks of the Ganga, is a particularly lawless town ruled by the father-son duo of Sadhu and Sundar Yadav (Mohan Joshi and Yashpal Sharma). Even the DIG of police, Amit's boss, and the state home minister turn their eyes away from the Yadavs' crimes.

Moreover, just about every officer working under Amit is on their payroll.



So when Amit tries to clean up the system, he meets with stiff resistance from within and without. His idealism rubs off on one of his subordinates, Bachha Yadav (Mukesh Tiwari), who turns against his mentor Sadhu Yadav and stands by his boss.

When Bachha and three of his subordinates vent their frustrations on two of Sundar's cronies in police lock-up by blinding them with acid (a reference to the Bhagalpur Blindings of 1979-1980 when 30 undertrials were blinded by policemen), the situation spirals into a crisis that gets out of everyone's hands, including that of the filmmaker.

Suddenly, Amit becomes a social crusader than cop, with the entire population of Tejpur standing by him. Good and evil neatly stack up against each other. There are tokenisms like a bad cop whom Amit has suspended suddenly reforming into an honest tea-stall owner, making a very mushy speech about his makeover with a Raj Kapoor song with a socialistic message playing in the background.

The symbolism of acid being described as the gangajal used to cleanse the system does not filter through the confusion of the post-interval mayhem.

But it is heartening to watch Jha's hero keep his idealism intact to the very end and not cop out and go on a killing spree like most other noble filmi policemen do in the name of justice.

While Gangaajal doesn't have anything original to say, it is well shot, well edited and brilliantly enacted by most of the lead actors. Cinematographer Arvind K's visuals lend tremendous character to the discontented yet deceptively calm temple town (shot in Wai, Maharashtra) where the plot unfolds.

Wayne Sharpe's background score is outstanding. There is a stream of restlessness in the seemingly serene notes of the fusion music used in the background track. The film has one song. One wishes directors would do away with these raunchy item numbers, irrespective of whether they are relevant to the storyline or not.

Oh for a heroine who has a role to play! Jha seems to have spent all his creative energies on writing the character of Amit Kumar, his deputies and adversaries and forgotten all about the SP's wife (Gracy Singh), whose only role in the proceedings is to warn her husband about the hazards of smoking, caution him against drinking too much and heating the food.

Worse, Gracy Singh doesn't attempt to lend colour to her screen self. She only makes the heroine look like a caricature. Mohan Joshi repeats his Mrityudand (also directed by Jha) act by playing the supercilious villain with vigour. Yashpal Sharma, on the other hand, has essayed the hedonistic bad man so often in his short career that he has become totally typecast.

One of the most engaging performances in the film comes from Mukesh Tiwari. After a hyped debut in Chinagate five years ago, he finally gets a role that offers scope for histrionics. He delivers the goods without much ado.

Ajay Devgan pulls up an ace with a part tailormade to reinforce his seething-under-the-surface angry hero image. To his credit (and the director's), he brings style and grace to a largely stereotypical, righteous protagonist. To a great extent, his presence covers up the film's patchiness in the second half.

Director Jha does not take the problems addressed by Shool and half-a-dozen other films on similar lines much further. Also, he is rather simplistic with his solutions. But considering the fact that you rarely get to see justice being done outside the fictional confines of the movie halls these days, Gangaajal does offer solace and a sense of retribution.

CREDITS
Cast: Ajay Devgan, Gracy Singh, Mohan Joshi, Mukesh Tiwari
Writer-Director: Prakash Jha
Music: Sandesh Shandilya
Producers: Entertainment One, Prakash Jha Productions




Edited By arsh on 1062170333


Top
 Profile  
 
 Post subject:
PostPosted: Fri Aug 29, 2003 3:48 pm 
Offline

Joined: Mon Dec 03, 2001 5:53 pm
Posts: 14989
indiafm trashes gangajal:

Gangaajal

By Taran Adarsh


Prakash Jha. The name is synonymous with meaningful cinema. Cinema that entertains and enlightens as well.

His latest offering GANGAAJAL bares open the jungle rule that's prevalent at some places of India and how an honest cop tries to root it out. Unfortunately, films of this genre have been attempted, recycled and repackaged in various avtaars on Hindi screen before, thereby giving the viewer a been-there-done-that kind of a feel.

By the river Ganga lies the imaginary district town of Tejpur in Bihar. Amit Kumar [Ajay Devgan] is the new Superintendent of Police.

In Tejpur, Amit encounters an ensemble of colourful characters. The uncrowned emperor, Sadhu Yadav [Mohan Joshi], his debauched son Sundar [Yashpal Sharma], the cops who turn a blind eye to the atrocities around…

Amit tries to breathe life into the decaying police force and some of his officers begin to trust him and respond. But the shackles of the corrupt system are too strong to break.

Inspiration gives way to frustration. This leads them to seek reckless solutions. And a weapon of revenge [acid] is accidentally discovered.

This weapon of purification becomes a symbol of purification in the hands of the common people. Suddenly, the society transforms into a mob on a crusade, seeking justice and revenge.

The ordinary citizen is suddenly empowered, but dangerously. Soon, the lines become blurred... What is right? What is just? Amit finds himself in a dilemma.

The story of GANGAAJAL bears a striking resemblance to the Manoj Bajpai starrer SHOOL. Of course, Prakash Jha has incorporated some true incidents [Bhagalpur blinding] in the film to make it look different from films of its ilk, but the essence remains the same.

The biggest drawback of the film, besides an oft-repeated plot, is that it's too grim, too dark and too depressing. In the current scenario, when feel-good entertainers are calling the shots, GANGAAJAL is too dry a subject that relies heavily on realism to the point that everything else takes a backseat.

There're no light moments, no romance whatsoever, just one song [that's non-appealing as well, picturised on a dancer!] and not many exciting moments.

Besides, there's an overdose of blood and gore, generous usage of expletives, an undercurrent of violence and tension throughout and sequences that perturb the viewer.

From the scripting point of view, the initial reels are extremely captivating. The introduction of a new character, be it a cop or a hooligan, every ten minutes of the film, keeps the interest alive.

The relevance of the title at the interval point is well explained, but the graph of the film slides downwards in the post-interval portions.

The story gets into the same-old good versus bad mould and it doesn't take much effort to guess what the next sequence would be like. Besides, the story has been stretched unnecessarily and the climax, which should've been a highpoint, is an absolute letdown.

Prakash Jha is not in form this time around. Though a good storyteller, he suffers on account of a skeletal, undernourished screenplay. Also, he has relied on a genre that holds scant novelty for the present-day audiences. The absence of songs and romance is also a major deterrent, which makes it a morbid experience.

Cinematography is alright. The locations of Wai give the film a fresh look. Dialogues are power-packed.

Ajay Devgan does his part exceedingly well, carrying the film on his firm shoulders. Gracy Singh suffers due to poor characterisation and even otherwise, fails to impress. Amongst a horde of character artistes, Yashpal Sharma leaves an indelible impression and Mukesh Tiwari is simply superb. Mohan Agashe and Mohan Joshi are as usual. Akhilendra Mishra is alright.

On the whole, GANGAAJAL has its limitations thanks to its oft-repeated theme. At the box-office, the film may appeal to a select few, but ladies and family audiences will keep away from a film of this genre. Business in U.P. and Bihar should prove to be the best.

Rating:- * *.


Top
 Profile  
 
Display posts from previous:  Sort by  
Post new topic Reply to topic  [ 3 posts ] 

All times are UTC


Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 5 guests


You cannot post new topics in this forum
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
You cannot edit your posts in this forum
You cannot delete your posts in this forum

Search for:
Jump to:  
Powered by phpBB® Forum Software © phpBB Group