Anybody know if the recently released Kal Ho Na Ho, Kuch Kuch Hota Hai, K3G retain the DVD Special Features on Blu Ray (and also the previously released Kabh Alvida Na Kehna)?

Many Thanks...

Apparently not. But does it matter when the picture quality looks like this? Stick with the DVD.



Absolutely disgraceful!

Haha! Good point I have not seen any SS yet so might wait for the reviews! Prob is my copy KKHH is the NON Anamorphic first rls....What to do!

(rant about apparently doctored stills removed)
Update: Apparently the old stills were not accurate so I'm reevaluating the situation. See posting below.

REM (regraded to match Yash Raj):

Yash Raj:

Though those shots comparison are awsome and truly prove the fact that a "picture is worth a thousand words". thanks Mhafner. if one wants to really learn meaning of how Soft focus, Edge enhancement, DNR or Grains affect PQ, this is a almost a reference shot for this purpose.

However i would have been happier if the twoshots were exactly same which they arent. He is closer to camera in YRF shot.

Exact same shot is not relevant here since it's not about compression, color/contrast or aspect ratio/framing details but the destructive effect of sledgehammer filtering applied with no taste or awareness of what it does, was designed for or should be used for, on the textures and look of images shot on film. The Yash version is reframed anyway. If I had quickly found the exact frame I would have used it though.

hmmm ive seen some more screenshots of this and they dont look as bad as the ones posted here?

See the screenshots from Blu-Ray.com to clear up any miss information the screen shots being bad, and etc.

http://forum.blu-ray.com/india/159766-k ... shots.html

Phew! Those shots still look less than perfect, but are far, far better. Must be a case of bad capturing software by the original poster.

Incidentally, I see some people at the Blu-ray.com forum are moaning about my choice of screenshot, saying that it is meant to look the way it does because it is an out-of-focus shot. They obviously didn't realise it was a good example since it illustrated the amount of grain reduction used. But no matter - the actual Blu-rays now do seem worth buying after all.

You mean I can replace my non anamorphic KKHH Just picked em up at £12 each (not a steal) but ok I suppose...

Ok, proper stills comparison this time:
Yash1
REM1
Yash2
REM2
Yash3
REM3
Yash4
REM4
Yash5
REM5
Yash6
REM6

So Yash is reframed, regraded (tendency to black crush and oversaturated colors), a bit sharpened, but not DNRed and apparently clean(er). Yash colors overall preferable it seems.

Based on these screenshots, the 'Yash Raj' K3G blu-ray seems to be a huge improvement over the atrocious REM version. While REM version is a complete disaster, the 'Yash Raj' version too seems to have it's share of problems. As pointed by 'mhafner', it clearly suffers from 'black crush' and 'over saturated colors'. There seems to be at least some contrast boost at play here.

@ sanjay and all.....i recomend all of you to have a look at screenshots of all 3 titles posted by rahul in SOME other site......all the 3 titles look promissing to me.....