Some excerpts from Sun Media DVD review:
http://www.ottawasun.com/Showbiz/Movies ... 6-sun.htmlTue, March 31, 2009
First-class SlumOscar miracle goes all out for the DVD release
By BRUCE KIRKLAND, SUN MEDIA
Confession: I was prepared to be disappointed with the first wave of Slumdog Millionaire DVDs.
Hallelujah! It is yet another triumph for the underdog. Films which have been so intensely scrutinized have a tendency to clunk, clatter and break down on their DVD debut.
GENEROUS EXTRAS:
It is not even a Special Edition. But it feels like it when you are watching the generous extras, which perfectly capture the feel of the project from its inception.
The DVD is a two-disc effort, although the second disc is reserved for the digital copy. All the extras are on disc one, along with a gorgeous widescreen transfer. Those extras are excellent, except for some of the poor quality video in the making-of scenes on set in Mumbai.
SPOILERS BELOW in quotes Quote:
There are 34 minutes of deleted scenes, some redeeming the tough police inspector played by Irrfan Khan, who authorizes the torture of Patel's character, Jamal, to get him to confess to fraud during his Millionaire run. In the final edit of the film, all he got was a glimmer. This is more satisfying.
Other deleted scenes provide more time with the three leads in the three phases of their lives together -- the two brothers and the girl who divides and even threatens to conquer them because of their jealousies and betrayals.
23-MINUTE DOC
The prime real estate is devoted to a 23-minute documentary, Slumdog Dreams: Danny Boyle and the Making of Slumdog Millionaire.
---------------------
Why some wanted extras missing: One of the crazy things about Oscars and DVDs is that actual footage of the Academy Awards is almost always missing.
There are rights issues.
The Academy owns its show and does not easily share it, although snippets of acceptance speeches from decades ago appear on some DVDs.
There are also timing issues. While most movies are still in the prime of their theatrical runs, the DVDs are mapped out, documentaries edited and commentaries completed.
So, by the time the DVD comes out, even the eight Oscars that Slumdog Millionaire won are not acknowledged properly.
I would love to see each of those awards being presented -- on the Slumdog DVDs which come out today. It is not to be. Nor do you get to see that on-stage party scene at the Kodak Theatre, with the entire cast and crew erupting in an inspired celebration.
Not all actually got nominated. For example, Indian co-director and casting director Loveleen Tandan never got her public due, because of the byzantine rules relating to Academy Awards credits. But many others did.
So here is who won Oscars for the movie: Best picture (producer Christian Colson); best director (Danny Boyle); best screenplay (Simon Beaufoy), best cinematography (Anthony Dod Mantle), best film editing (Chris Dickens), best original score (A.R. Rayman), best original song (Jai Ho, by Rahman and Gulzar), and best sound (Ian Tapp, Richard Pryke, Resul Pookutty).